Though initially emotionally devastated by their loss of their church building, members gathered and emotions turned to determination not to let the enemy destroy their congregation. It was soon decided by unanimous decision to rebuild. The slogan “Mt. Pleasant Strong” was inspiring.

A group from the church met with the Coordinating Team of Beaver-Butler Presbytery to discuss the future of the congregation. With concerns about declining membership in the presbytery, a merger with another church was suggested. After several weeks and additional meetings, and the disclosure that insurance money could only go toward rebuilding, the Presbytery gave Mt. Pleasant Church their blessing to rebuild.

Member Walter Parish took on the task of compiling an itemized list of property losses. Each item was given an estimated replacement cost. A rebuilding estimate of 1.5 million dollars was presented to the congregation. An audit was also conducted to ensure all items were included. An architect was hired and a time schedule was proposed.

The congregation was adamant that the new building would resemble the old one with a cathedral style ceiling, raised chancel, front foyer, stained glass windows and a steeple. Sadly, salvaging the original steeple was not feasible and a new one would need to be built. 

In the wake of loss, they witnessed something extraordinary—their church was not only rebuilt in structure but strengthened in spirit. What once stood as a building has now become a powerful symbol of unity, generosity, and unwavering faith.

The journey would not have been possible without the incredible outpouring of support from so many. Members of the congregation, friends, neighbors, and the greater community came together in ways that truly embodied what it means to serve one another. 

A Spaghetti Dinner fundraiser was organized by First United Presbyterian Church of Darlington and The Galilean Presbyterian Church of New Galilee along with a Fund Raiser BBQ Dinner organized by Prayer Mountain Ministries. 

Many individuals contributed—whether through financial donations, countless volunteer hours, skilled labor, or simple acts of kindness. From those who cleaned and cleared debris, prepared meals to keep workers going, to those who gave quietly and generously behind the scenes—every effort mattered, and every contribution made a difference.

Special recognition is given to Walter Parish, who served as the lead overseer of this project. His dedication, leadership, and tireless commitment helped guide this vision into reality. Alongside him, Rich McCarty and Jim Swagger gave countless hours, working diligently and faithfully to ensure that progress never stopped.

Every committee member who planned, organized, and problem-solved…every volunteer who showed up ready to work…every person who donated time, money, materials, or expertise—created a foundation not just of bricks and mortar, but of perseverance and hope.

Demolition by Nicely Contracting began on May 31, 2022 and rebuilding by ME Builders and Supply began on January 30, 2023 with new exterior framing erected by a contractor. Once under roof, other work that was contracted out included electrical by TEC Electrical, plumbing by Potts Plumbing, and HVAC Air Systems. Flooring and carpeting was installed by Ferrante Upholstery and Masonry by Pratt/Hall. Pew installation was completed by outside companies, as well.